I had the same problem. I mailed a check.
On the bottom left of the home page is Frank Devine’s address. You can send him a check made out to “Frank Devine”.
I think the badges are sold by Bill Collins 201-933-1442.
I am sure if you contact these guys via private message here or phone, you can e-mail a PayPal payment to both by getting their PayPal e-mail addresses or mail either/both a check.